Pete and Daniel
This is your space, use it in whatever ways feel useful to you and your project.
This is your space, use it in whatever ways feel useful to you and your project.
Pluta lives in Ward 2
Wards do not have same demographics from precinct to precinct
Who is on the ballot from year to year (ex. 2007 mayor uncontested)
Younger, more affluent, more liberal, pretty white voters going for Morse (perhaps partly because of a narrative about unity)
Ther eis no such constituency in Springfield
Casino polarization
Neither campaign particularly effective at mobilizing underrepresented groups or reducing disparities
The race was decided based on effectiveness of conventional campaigns
Here are my thoughts/notes/findings from our interviews, along with some analysis.
From Rebecca Lisi meeting:
Ward 5 is west holyoke, more repub/rural/conservative... 5b is more dense, 5a is more rural and detached from holyoke's urban core.
Ward 7 is professors priced out from Noho
Lisi: "Alex generated hype around who he was and what he was doing... didn't literally go to every door... people whose door he didn't go to weren't engaged, and these same people lack the ability or venue to say that to anyone"
"The machismo latino demographic would prefer hetero woman over gay male" ... but any antigay sentiment did not occur in elite areas so it was never broadcast into the political arena.
Wards 3/4/7 had incumbent councilors stepping down. these races were hotly contested and could've increased turnout in these wards
Pluta looked bad after the “Snowtober” storm, "poor presence" no emergency meeting and the quick recovery was not attributed to her, Morse was out giving donuts to workers
Betty meeting:
Morse speaking Spanish is big - he can listen and hear, connect. Grew up in Holyoke and the majority of his friends are Latino. Betty remembers him campaigning and using a line like "the majority of my friends didn't have the same privileges I had"
Pluta is French-Canadian and lacked a church community
The Puerto Ricans in Holyoke are typically lower class, undereducated, but betty believes that they'd vote in PR and are less interested in voting here (Remember, Puerto Ricans have full voting rights as American citizens)
"Ward 7 is running Alex's agenda"
Elaine/Nelson:
2a is her ward - they love her.
They imagined wards 1/2/3 saying to Morse "you can speak our language but you don't understand our issues"
Nelson: "our make or breaks were 4/5/7"
Elaine said: Other people advised them "don't touch Latinos until August because they move a lot," Nelson disagrees with this portrayal of Latinos
Like Lisi said, mayoral race was impacted by city councilor races
500 people who had never voted before came out, Nelson claims they registered 100-150 of them
In wards 6 and 7 people were still turning out after 6pm, they knew that was a bad sign
Pluta has gone door to door, too, but she couldn't as mayor, she was too busy
Morse:
Pluta's first campaign chair was brother of indicted fire chief
Ward 7 took a while to get on board with him
He attributes a lot of his success to his door knocking and his ability to speak Spanish
Gladys's bilingual campaign mailings were helpful
Morse knew he could win the election without wards 1+2
No one showed up at Latinos por Pluta
Below are my notes after interviews in Holyoke with Councilmember Rebecca Lisi, community organizer Betty Medina-Lichetenstein, former Mayor Elaine Pluta and her campaign manager Nelson Roman, MassLive reporter Greg Saulmon, and Mayor Alex Morse and his staff.
I organized my notes thematically, synthesizing the key ideas that surfaced across several days/weeks' worth of interviews. I believe they tell a nuanced and accurate narrative of the 2011 Holyoke mayoral election. Integrating them with Pete's and Aron's notes, which were created independently, only makes the story richer.
This was an outline Aron created, it offers a rough picture of how each conversation was structured:
I created the first three charts, Aron created the last two (named "trends")
During our interviews, the "trends" charts were very useful because they succintly demonstrate how voter participation varies with minority population (and it's easy to see the exceptions)
This was the final data I produced on Holyoke using GIS. The map and accompanying table displays demographic information derrived by matching block-level census data with Holyoke wards.
The third attachment, an Excel sheet entitled "Census Ward Match-Up," displays the block-by-block data. In other words, it shows how we got to the totals displayed in the first two documents. Importantly, it also lists which blocks fall into which wards -- a resource now available for future researchers who do not know GIS but wish to use census data to analyze any sort of question in Holyoke.
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
23.99 KB | |
Holyoke Ward Data.xls | 18.5 KB |
Census Ward Match-Up.xls | 554 KB |
The attached image is an original creation, the product of 2010 US Census Block level data, a Holyoke Ward map provided by Jeffrey Burkott of the Holyoke Planning Department, and about 15hrs spent in Smudd.
Our Holyoke voter data is organized by ward (as Pete's analysis shows). However, Holyoke does not have recent demographic information available by ward. We had to create that information ourselves using data from the US Census Bureau. Using a mapping program I learned last year called ArcGIS, I matched US Census Blocks with the wards they fell into and derrived demographic data for each of the seven Holyoke wards. This data is depicted in the attached map.* I also was able to derrive data for the 18+ (voting age) population of each ward, which is not depicted in the map but will be important for our final report.
* This depiction considers minorities to be all people not single-race white, as counted by the 2010 US Census. In actuality, though, the minority populations should be significantly larger; currently, the data does not include white Hispanics as a part of the minority population. A future draft of this map, to be created later this week, will consider minorities to be all people not single-race, non-Hispanic whites, as counted by the 2010 US Census.