Timeline for Moodle

Timeline for move to Moodle, 12 -18 months
 
·     Meeting with interested/invested faculty early next week

·     Meeting with the CEP –ASAP – 2 FCC committee members

·     Meeting with theCo6- ASAP - 2 FCC committee members

·     Recommendation/meeting with Greg Call

·     Announcement to Faculty  - May 3rd Faculty Meeting

·     Focus group #1, 5 Faculty? -  Migrate during Summer 2011 – run test courses Fall 2011 to determine needs and bugs.

·     Focus Group #2, 10-20 Faculty, Migrate during January 2012, run test courses, Spring 2012 determine bugs, needs and upgrades.

·     Migrate all Faculty, or as many as we can Summer 2012, complete migration January 2013

·     Go live Fall 2012 or Spring 2013 Depending on how we are doing

-   Blackboard discontinued June 2012

·     CMS-LMS down December 2013

April 5, 2011

Reasons to Drop Blackboard
 

  • Diminishing support and increased costs -- Blackboard has been diminishing support for smaller institutions, future development of Blackboard are driven by their core customer base (large institutions who are more profitable) and increasing licensing costs. As a result, liberal arts colleges have been dropping Blackboard at an increasing rate and moving to Moodle.

  • Courses are closed

  • Predatory company

  • Blackboard is a proprietary system that may not be customized to evolve with the needs of our faculty.

  • Intellectual property of faculty used in courses can only be extracted from Blackboard with great difficulty.

  • Blackboard can not be modified to integrate more effectively with other institutional resources and repositories.

 

 Reasons to Move to Moodle

 

  • Promote collaboration among five college institutions -- Smith, Hampshire, UMass have already either moved or are in the process of moving to Moodle. MHC is also seriously considering moving to Moodle. If all 5C schools were on Moodle, we can collaborate on development and possibly share resources between systems. Smith and Hampshire are already members of a consortium of liberal arts colleges that customize Moodle for the liberal arts context. Amherst could participate in this group.

  

  • Reduce development costs -- customizing existing features is much more cost-effective than building from scratch.

 

  • Moodle supports the Shibboleth single sign-on solution -- five college institutions will be implementing Shibboleth for authentication in the coming year or so. Moodle already supports Shibboleth and Hampshire has already implemented Shibboleth for Moodle authentication.

  

  • Moodle uses the same core technologies as Drupal (CMS), which should simplify integrating Drupal and Moodle to create a more seamless user experience.
Issues from the Faculty's perspective
Issues from an IT perspective

 

Feature Blackboard Moodle 
Forum YY
    SubscriptionNY
    Read TrackingYY
   Grading/RatingNY
   Group ForumsYY
   Date conditional accessYY
   Grade conditional accessNY
   Locked postings (no replies)YY
   Read/Unread postingsYN (missing from 2.0 so far)
   Collect postingsYN 
   Archived threadsYY
   Anonymous postsYN  
   AttachmentsYY
   Author can removeY (optional setting)Y (capability)
   Author can editY (optional setting)Y (for specified time) capability
   Block specific usersYY (capability)
   Move thread to other forumNY (capability)
   Multiple forum formatsNY 
   SearchableYY (more ways) 
File Upload YY
   From local/network drivesYY
   From internal repositoryNY
   From external repositoriesNY 
URL item YY
Written item (CMS article)YY
Page item YY
Internal Course Link YN
Folder item YY (limited contents)
Assignments YY
   Multiple assignment typesNY
Sound Input Y (with Wimba license)Y
Wiki NY
Quiz YY
   Number of question types911
   Feedback by questionYY
   Feedback by quizNY (variable by performance)
   Question poolYY
   Multiple attemptsYY (can specify how many)
   TimerYY
   Force CompletionYY (tied to multiple attempts)
  Access controlled by date/timeYY
   Password controlled accessYY
   Presentation modesYY (more modes)
   Shuffle question orderNY
   Access controlled by another gradeNY
GradebookYY
   Weighting by category and itemsYY
   Grade display options53
   Download gradesY (2 delimited formats)Y (4 formats)
   Report can rank studentNY
   Drop lowest X gradesNY
DropboxYN (use assignment)
File sharingY (for groups only or use discussion board)Y (Use forum)
Course copyYY (Use backup/restore)
ChatYY
CalendarYY (Block)
Use trackingYY
Role SwitchingNY
GroupsYY (used more places and better integrated)