- 1968: David Cichon ’70, St. Louis Cardinals
- 1970: Barry Roderick ’71, Minnesota Twins
- 1970: Robert Jones ’71, Atlanta Braves
- 1971: Richard Bedard ’71, Pittsburgh Pirates
- 1971: Robert Jones ’71, Pittsburgh Pirates
- 1972: Donnelly Douglas ’73, Texas Rangers
- 1973: Donnelly Douglas ’73, Texas Rangers
- 1975: Mark Woodbrey ’75, San Francisco Giants
- 1977: Bill Swiacki ’78, Boston Red Sox
- 1978: Bill Swiacki ’78, Los Angeles Dodgers
- 1980: Rich Thompson ’80, Cleveland Indians
- 1981: John Cerutti ’82, Toronto Blue Jays
- 1982: David McCarthy ’82, Cleveland Indians
- 1982: Michael Lavery ’82, Toronto Blue Jays
- 1984: Kyle O’Brien ’84, Atlanta Braves
- 2000: Hugh Quattlebaum ’00, Detroit Tigers
Source: Major League Baseball