Final project guidelines
FYS 2011
Final Project
What does your final project entail?
DEADLINES
Please note that no extension will be granted for any of these deadlines. If for any reason you are not able to meet them, you will have to secure your class dean’s permission for an extension.
First of all, you will have to turn in, by Thursday 10/27 at 11,30 AM, a one-page (either single or double-spaced) description of your final project (of course in progress, and just in case you forgot, will be due on 12/20 by noon). In this description, you can be as detailed or as vague as need may be, but make sure you include at least your name, possibly a title in progress, and for sure a thesis, and a goal (or a set of goals).
In either case, you can be as creative or as conservative as you wish. I will be happy to provide you with specific paper topics, if you want to write a research paper or an analytical study of a particular text or issue (see also the attached information below about research essays and creative projects respectively).
Some of you have already begun working on this project, and I have been talking to many of you about various possibilities. But I want you all to begin to focus and get to work.
In the case of collective projects, please make sure that you also think concretely about work division and about the specific tasks that each of the group members will perform and include them in your outline. You can turn in a group outline as well, but then you should each write a personal statement, explaining why this project is meaningful and relevant for each of you.
The one page write-up, on which you will receive feedback if necessary, is meant to help you. How, you will ask?
You should see this assignment as an opportunity to not only present your work, but also use your professor as a resource for refining your ideas. Consider ways in which your write-up might generate comments or suggestions that are helpful to you in completing the project. If you are running into problems in realizing your goals, think of ways in which you might use this assignment to articulate the problem or issue you are dealing with.
You are strongly encouraged to include something concrete in your outline. Even if your project is not complete or fully realized, this can be extremely useful especially in the places where you are running into problems or obstacles. I encourage all of you to come and speak to me, in any case, but especially if you have not yet done so. If you cannot come to office hours, as always, write an email and we can try to set up an appointment. We can always talk by phone or email. Please do not keep questions and doubts to yourselves!
FYSE 2011
1. Final paper guidelines
OBJECTIVES: To develop your ability to conduct independent and original research on a topic that is of interest to you; to convey the results of that research in a lively, intelligent voice in a thesis-support format.
AUDIENCE: The members of the class, who are familiar with the materials and issues covered in class, but not necessarily with the specific topic of your research.
LENGTH: 10-15 pages. The paper should be double-spaced in 12-point Times New Roman or equivalent font with 1-inch margins all around. A title page is appreciated. Proofread before submitting.
PREPARATION: Coming up with a topic for a research paper is difficult, but it is part of the development of your critical skills. You can focus on a particular text, on a particular time period, on one of the abstract concepts developed in class, or even on cross-cultural and comparative issues. You should choose a topic that is sufficiently narrow and avoid a topic that is too broad or too vague. The most important thing is to pick a topic that is of great interest to you, since you will be spending many hours thinking about it. Once you have a topic, you should formulate a question that will control and drive your research. What would you like to know about a topic that you do not already know? The question provides a clear focus for your research and a clear goal for your writing. A research project always involves three processes: conducting the research, understanding the results of that research, and writing an accurately documented paper based on your research. You can use any combination of primary and secondary sources, and there is no minimum or maximum number of sources you must use; let the research topic guide you in selecting useful sources. It is perfectly acceptable to use materials covered in class, but you should either develop an original approach to those materials or treat them in more depth than we are able to do during regular classes. The final product should not only report the results of your research, but should also supply an answer to your research question, which means having a specific, argumentative thesis.
DOCUMENTATION: You can use either MLA or Chicago style, but be consistent about documentation. Include a bibliography at the end of your paper.
GRADING: See the separate Grading Criteria sheet.
DEADLINES: A preliminary thesis and working bibliography are due on Thursday, October 27 by class time, which will be held in Frost Library to help you discover the research tools at your disposal; you can send this as an email attachment. The final product is due on Tuesday December 20th by 2:00 pm. The final paper must be turned in as a hard copy. A final paper sent electronically will not be accepted.
2. Creative project guidelines:
OBJECTIVES: To develop your ability to translate your understanding of at least one facet of dream culture in China into the artistic medium and format of your choice (fiction; visual arts; fashion; and so on) in a lively, intelligent, and intelligible voice.
AUDIENCE: The members of the class, who are familiar with the materials and issues covered in class, but not necessarily with the specific approach to the subject matter.
LENGTH: This, of course, will vary widely, depending on the project you will choose to realize. In the case of collective projects, please make sure that you also think concretely about work division and about the specific tasks that each of the group members will perform and include them in your outline. You can turn in a group outline and statement as well on the respective due dates, but each participant should attach a personal statement, explaining why this project is meaningful and relevant for each of you.
Regardless of length and format of the project, you will need to include an analytical explanation of your work of at least five pages. This should be a sort of “artist’s statement,” in which you introduce your project, explain why you chose a certain format for it, and also how you think it relates to the course subject matter. The statement should be double-spaced in 12-point Times New Roman or equivalent font with 1-inch margins all around. Proofread before submitting.
PREPARATION: regardless of the creative format you choose (video, dance, music, painting, and so on and so forth) you should view this process as an integral part of the development of your critical skills. You can focus on a particular issue (i.e., dream interpretation), on one of the abstract concepts developed in class (e.g., gender performance), or even on cross-cultural and comparative issues (for instance, dream interpretation in China and Tibet). The most important thing is to pick a topic that is of great interest to you, since you will be spending many hours thinking about it. Once you have a topic, you should formulate a question that will control and drive your work. You can use any combination of primary and secondary sources, and there is no minimum or maximum number of sources you must use; let your muses guide you in selecting useful sources. It is perfectly acceptable to use materials covered in class, but you should either develop an original approach to those materials or treat them in more depth than we are able to do during regular classes. All work for this assignment must be turned in as hard copy.
DOCUMENTATION: For the written portion of your project, you can use either MLA or Chicago style, but be consistent about documentation. Include a bibliography, if relevant, at the end of your paper.
DEADLINES: A preliminary thesis and working bibliography are due on Thursday, October 27 by class time, which will be held in Frost Library to help you discover the research tools at your disposal; you can send this as an email attachment. The final product is due on Tuesday December 20th by 2:00 pm.
Grading Criteria
For formal essays in first-year seminars
A Paper: The principle characteristic of the A paper is its rich content. The paper is imaginative and contains striking, original, and memorable ideas. It has a clear thesis supported by excellent detail and evidence. The A paper is also marked by stylistic finesse: the title and opening paragraph are engaging; the transitions are artful; the phrasing is tight, fresh, and highly specific; the sentence structure is varied; the tone enhances the purposes of the paper; and it is almost entirely free of mechanical errors. That is, the A paper exhibits consciousness of the full possibilities of the English language and, because of its careful organization, development, and clarity, leaves the reader eager to reread the piece and tell others about it.
When the essay has a research component, the A paper not only develops ideas and conclusions with ample support, but also uses primary and secondary source material artfully and engages in a significant dialogue with the opinions of others in order to advance its argument.
B Paper: It is significantly better than competent, and while not as artful as the A paper, the B paper delivers substantial information. Its specific points are logically ordered, well developed, and unified around a clear organizing principle that is apparent in the paper. The opening paragraph draws the reader in while delineating the goals of the paper; the closing paragraph is both conclusive and connected to the opening. The transitions between paragraphs are reasonably smooth and the sentence structures are pleasingly varied. The diction of the B paper is both more precise and more concise than average. On the whole, the B paper makes the reading experience a pleasurable one, for it offers substantial information with few distractions and mechanical errors.
When the essay has a research component, the B paper develops ideas and conclusions with ample support, and secondary sources are used with a clear purpose.
C Paper: The C paper is competent, fulfills the assignment, and is reasonably well organized. The actual information it delivers, however, is thin, predictable, and perhaps even fairly self-evident. Its ideas are typically cast in the form of vague generalities. Stylistically the C paper has significant shortcomings: the opening paragraph does little to draw the reader in or state the aims of the paper; the final paragraph offers only a perfunctory wrap-up; the transitions between paragraphs are often bumpy; the sentences are monotonous and choppy; and the diction is marked by repetition and imprecision. On the whole, the C paper is stylistically flat and lacking in the originality and imagination that characterizes the A and B papers.
When the essay has a research component, the C paper develops ideas and conclusions logically, but without showing very much command or critical awareness of primary and secondary sources.
D Paper: Its treatment and development of the subject are undeveloped. While organization is present, it is neither clear nor effective. Sentences are frequently awkward, ambiguous, and marred by serious mechanical errors. Evidence of careful proofreading is scanty. The D paper gives the impression of having been conceived and written in haste.
When the essay involves a research component, the D paper may refer to primary and secondary sources, but fails to use them in a meaningful and effective way.
F Paper: Its treatment of the subject is superficial; its theme lacks discernable organization; its prose is garbled and stylistically awkward. Mechanical errors are frequent. The F paper exhibits ideas, organization, and style below the acceptable level of college writing.
When the essay involves a research component, the F paper fails to meet the requirements and standards for the use of primary and secondary source material.