To me, music is a lot of things. Music is comfort, familiarity, joy, solace, and catharsis. Different bands and songs have meant different things to me at various points in my life. I began my love of music at a very young age; there is an embarrassing home video somewhere of a toddler Jake dancing wildly to Back in Black by AC/DC. I grew up listening to bootleg CDs of live performances by U2 in my dad's truck, which he collected avidly. To this day, hearing the sweeping, all-encompassing grandiosity of The Edge's guitar work fills me with a nostalgia-tinged sense of awe.
My deep affection for music is what inspires me to keep hard copies of my favourite albums. Whilst I consider my Spotify Premium subscription an investment about as valuable as my campus meal plan, there is nothing like having a physical, tangible object that you can hold and admire. Vinyl allows a wonderfully analogue music experience, requiring one to carefully place a record on a turntable and gently apply the needle to begin play. Records and their sleeves are also aesthetically pleasing items, making them good for collecting. There is something satisfyingly intentional about picking one record out of a stack to listen to in that moment rather than passively hitting the shuffle button on a digital player.
Missing my vinyl collection while at school, I decided when I visited home in May that I would pack up my turntable and records and ship them out to Massachusetts, where they arrived a few days after I did. I was delighted to have my albums, but over the past year I had accrued a long list of new ones to add to the collection. It was time to go vinyl hunting.
Below are four places to dig through stacks in the Five College area that are easily accessible via public transportation. I write this guide so that aspiring Amherst audiophiles might be inspired to do some digging themselves, and perhaps uncover a new favourite in the process.
Mystery Train Records - Amherst, MA
Source: Amherst Business Improvement District
The first of two traditional record stores I've found in the valley, Mystery Train is the most convenient establishment in this list. It's located in the town centre, only a few minutes by foot from campus. It's hard to spot, hidden at the end of an alleyway not immediately visible from the street. The building is an old house of traditional New England style that has been converted into a music shop. It's not particularly big, and the fact that every corner is stuffed with records, CDs, and books gives the place a disorganized crowdedness that feels like it's from another era. Mystery Train looks like it would've looked in 1987, and shopping there makes you feel like everyone else in the place has more legit music cred than you do from spending years involved in the local underground music scene. They carry plenty of 45s and specialize in older records, with only a handful of new albums available. There is also a robust selection of genres other than rock and pop, particularly jazz, Latin, and international music. I particularly like Mystery Train because it feels properly authentic, a labour of love by its owner without pretense or frill.
Recommended if: you want a classic rock album or something from a less widespread genre.
My purchase: "Go Your Own Way/Silver Springs" (1976) by Fleetwood Mac
Turn It Up - Northampton, MA
The other traditional record store I've found is Turn It Up in Northampton, a few blocks from the Smith College campus. Located in the basement of a large commercial structure, the shop has a sidewalk entrance that sits at the bottom of an unassuming staircase. Turn It Up has a similar general collection as Mystery Train, specializing in older records from the 1980s and earlier. A surprising amount of shelf real estate is given to other merchandise in addition to vinyl, particularly CDs and DVDs. They also, interestingly, carry a selection of old video games that would appeal to the gaming nostaligiac. An original PlayStation sits behind the counter for sale. Turn It Up stocks more new vinyl than Mystery Train and reserves space for records by local artists.
Recommended if: you have multimedia purchasing interests or if you want a more comprehensive discography of your favourite 70s rock band.
My purchase: "The Unforgettable Fire" (1984) by U2
Newbury Comics - Northampton, MA
Source: Newbury Comics
Down the block from Turn it Up is Newbury Comics, a New England/New York based chain of pop-culture stores. Walking into a Newbury Comics, the vibe is roughly comic book shop meets Hot Topic meets record store. There is plenty to see, from rainbow flag pride socks to politically charged bumper stickers to Pusheen graphic tees. It's a cute store for the pop-culture savvy Gen Z, staffed by friendly twenty-somethings and serving a sassy brand of cool designed to appeal to a young crowd. As part of that appeal, Newbury is riding the wave of the vinyl revival, stocking plenty of the contemporary indie and R&B albums that their demographic is after. Whether I like it or not, I am most definitely part of that target demographic, and I love Newbury's vinyl offerings; I had to restrain myself from spending my entire paycheque on records. The major difference in terms of selection is Newbury's focus on new releases, with a regular repertoire of your favourite indie band's most recent works. This also means that most of their stock is still in its plastic wrap and therefore more expensive than the primarily used record selection at the previous two establishments. Newbury does, however, have a section of used vinyl and respectable offerings of classic artists that have experienced cultural longevity.
Recommended if: you think the other stores only stock albums your dad would listen to.
My purchase: The Head and the Heart self-titled debut (2011) limited edition orange vinyl
Barnes & Noble - Hadley, MA
Everyone's favourite big-box bookstore has, in its continuing effort to avoid going the way of Borders, branched out in recent years to sell merchandise outside of its traditional specialty. This includes a selection of vinyl in most B&N media sections. If I'm around the Hampshire Mall and I need to wait for the bus, I often will head across the street to get a cup of coffee at the in-store cafe. Now that I have my turntable, sifting through the shelves of records has become a pleasant part of that post-Target run routine. Unsurprisingly, there is no used vinyl at B&N, so be prepared to pay new vinyl prices. There is an obvious pop bent in the artists whose music is stocked there, but you can also find classic rock, indie, hip-hop, and a surprisingly consistent selection of film soundtracks. The options are the fewest here than anywhere else, but if you're looking for an artist that features on top 40 radio stations, then this might be your best bet.
Recommended if: your tastes are modern and mainstream and you know there's nothing wrong with that, or if you were going to stop and get a book anyway so might as well, right?
My purchase: The Lumineers self-titled debut (2012)