Submitted by Matthew Schulkind on Friday, 4/10/2009, at 2:36 PM

There are so many provocative issues raised by this film that we could discuss.  I’ll make a few suggestions, but feel free to comment on any aspect of the movie that interests you. 
Do you think either the father or the son is guilty?  What evidence leads you to this conclusion?  Are you certain enough of your decision to convict given the legal standard (beyond a reasonable doubt)?  The other brothers seem convinced of their family members’ innocence.  How is that possible?  What would you respond to someone who claimed to have a recovered memory of an abusive episode from their childhood?